When Stuart suggests that actress Reagan Lauren Busch star in their new picture, Peter agrees and asks for an audition. However, wanting to be a player in his own right, Stuart insists that he be allowed to make the deal.
Following his death from a heart attack, Peter comes face to face with God. When his promise to be a nicer person allows him to negotiate a deal, Peter returns to life to finish Beverly Hills Gun Club.
During a meeting at the studio, Stuart recommends Neil Patrick Harris for the lead in Beverly Hills Gun Club, while Bobby has his mind set on James Van Der Beek.
As a result of all his hard work, screenwriter Adam Rafkin has been hospitalized. To help cheer him up, Peter arrives with their film's new leading man, Cole Ricardi. However, Adam's recovery is set back when Cole reveals his script changes.